Our final 2018 post focused on what we thought was the biggest case of that year, and which, we’re predicting, will be the biggest case of 2019: Knick v. Township of Scott, No. 17-647, that’s the one in which the Supreme Court is considering whether federal takings claims can be brought in federal court, and whether to revisit the 30-year old Williamson County “state procedures” requirement.
So we’re kicking off 2019 with our thoughts on that case, coming up for reargument next week.
Before we get to our prognostication (yes, we’re going to go there, however futile doing so might be), we wanted to lay out our thinking on the issues so you can see how we got there. The wildly divergent positions taken by the three main players — Ms. Knick, the Township, and the United States — illustrate well how mucked up and opaque regulatory takings