Development agreements

Subscribe to Development agreements via RSS

You know how we’re always saying that certain parties have an enviable record of success in the Hawaii Supreme Court? Well, now the statistics are official.

The latest edition of the University of Hawaii Law Review published an article by lawprof David Callies summarzing the decisions of the court during the tenure of now-retired Chief Justice Ronald Moon. The article sets forth the stark numbers (83% win rate, 65% reversal of the intermediate appellate court), and contains a sharp comment about the often-lengthy nature of the court’s opinions:

Second, the Moon Court decided some of thestate’s most important property and related environmental and Native Hawaiianrights cases in favor of the various non-governmental organizations bringingthem (Sierra Club, Earthjustice, Hawaii’s Thousand Friends, and the NativeHawaiian Legal Corporation) approximately eighty-two percent of the time,sixty-five percent of which reversed the Intermediate Court of Appeals (ICA).Third, the court increasingly rendered lengthy opinions, many triple the…

Continue Reading U.H. Lawprof: HAWSCT’s 1993-2010 Record On Private Property Rights “Appalling”

13.LULHIIt’s back! Time once again for the bi-annual Hawaii Land Use Law Conference, to be held January 17 and 18, 2013 (Thursday and Friday) at the Downtown YWCA (a very convenient venue).

Planning co-chairs Professor David Callies and Ben Kudo have once again assembled a stellar faculty and put together an agenda that covers most topics of interest.

We’ll be moderating a panel on “Development Through Exemptions – The Evolution of Reclassifications, Permitting, Land Use &Development in Hawaii: The Unintended Consequences ofan Increasingly Complex System of Regulations,” featuring panelists Linda L.W. Chow (Deputy Attorney General State of Hawaii), Oswald K. Stender (Office of Hawaiian Affairs), and Kali Watson (Hawaiian Community Development).

Two highlights of the conference:

First, Mike Berger will give the keynote presentation on our favorite topic, regulatory takings: “Taking a Critical Look at 30 Years of the Supreme Court’s Taking Jurisprudence.” Mike has taken the lead in…

Continue Reading Mark Your Calendars: 10th Hawaii Land Use Law Conference (Jan. 17-18, 2013)

For those of you sticking around Chicago after the ABA Annual Meeting, there’s the opportunity for even more land use, zoning, takings, and condemnation programming. ALI-CLE (fka ALI-ABA) is putting on it’s annual Land Use Institute later this week. It looks like Planning Co-Chairs Gideon Kanner and Frank Schnidman have put together a wide-ranging agenda, and stellar faculty, as usual. 

Details, including registration information, here.Continue Reading Chicago Part II: Land Use Institute

For those who listened in to the just-concluded “Recent Developments in Eminent Domain” teleconference, thank you. Here are the links to the cases and briefs that we discussed that were not included in your written materials. Also, click on the link above to order the audio CD of the program if you missed out.

  • Are interlocutory public use determinations immediately appealable? Some courts say no. Others say yes. 
  • More on the California Supreme Court’s opinion validating the legislature’s elimination of redevelopment agencies. Follow the issue at the California Eminent Domain Report. 

Continue Reading Links From Today’s Eminent Domain Teleconference

A must read: our Owners’ Counsel of America colleague Michael Rikon, the doyen of New York’s eminent domain bar, has published “I Represented The Devil Of Brooklyn,” in the Practical Real Estate Lawyer. As Mike writes, “it wasn’t a demonic fight in front of the hot dog line at Nathan’s in Coney Island … this legal tale is about a property owner in Prospect Heights who had the absolute gall to object to the taking of his property for an arena and related real estate development by a well-connected real estate developer.”

If that sounds familiar, it is: Mike represented Daniel Goldstein, the plaintiff-in-chief in the multi-jurisdiction Atlantic Yards eminent domain fight, and the protagonist of the documentary Battle for Brooklyn in the final condemnation case in New York’s courts. Other lawyers had handled Goldstein’s attempt to stop the condemnation and the environmental challenges, and…

Continue Reading “I Represented The Devil Of Brooklyn”

Here’s one for your California readers. You know Proposition 13, the provision in the California Constitution that limits property tax increases, and allows reassessment of value only upon a change of ownership, and you either love it or hate it: to some it insulates property owners from being forced out of their homes by uncontrolled property taxes, to others it is responsible for the downfall of California as the Golden State.

A property owner’s acquisition of replacement property for property taken in “eminent domain proceedings” in which the taken property is acquired by a “public entity,” is not a “change of ownership.” But what about when new property is purchased to replace property sold under threat of condemnation to a private developer who is teamed up with a government redevelopment agency — is that a “change of ownership” such that the property is assessed at current market rates?

In …

Continue Reading Cal App: Sale To Private Redeveloper Under Threat Of Condemnation Is A “Change Of Ownership” Under Prop 13

Here’s what we’re reading today:

  • Oakland budget cuts his zoo, Children’s Fairyland – from the San Francisco Chronicle: “In all, more than $28 million will be sliced from the budget, mostly from the $388 million general fund. The cuts are due to the loss of redevelopment funds, which Oakland used to fund services and programs across the city. ‘It’s not clean and neat. We wish it were,’ said Mayor Jean Quan. ‘For California’s older, larger cities, like Oakland, losing these redevelopment funds has been very, very tough.'”
  • Redevelopment Agencies Facing Default – from Cal Watchdog: “The Legislation canceled the RDAs’ tax increment-financing, which served as their piggy-bank under the Community Redevelopment Law for the past 65 years.  The California Legislature and its crony capitalist allies will desperately try to resurrect new tax and economic incentives to reclaim their ability to interfere in the California real estate markets.”

…
Continue Reading Tuesday Round Up: Cal Redevelopment Drawdown To Hurt Animals, Children; Thank You Public Workers For Saving Hawaii

Roxie_logoSan Francisco Bay Areans: come join us at the Roxie Theater (3117 16th Street between Valencia and Guerrero, San Francisco) tonight for screenings of Battle for Brooklyn, the Oscar-shortlisted documentary film about the Atlantic Yards eminent domain case. Two shows, 7:00 and 9:00 p.m. Details, including ticket purchase here.

I’ll be there to answer questions on the legal aspects of the film, as well as discuss its relevance to California, where redevelopment and eminent domain abuse are front page stories due to the California Supreme Court’s recent decision upholding the Legislature’s abolishment of the state’s 400+ redevelopment agencies.

Also showing is “The Tragedy of Eminent Domain: The destruction and survival of a New York City neighborhood.” This short tells the story of how a project called “Manhattantown” destroyed a historic African-American community on the Upper West Side in the 1950s. Manhattantown set the model…

Continue Reading Tonight: San Francisco Screenings Of “Battle For Brooklyn” At The Roxie

Here’s what we’re reading today:

  • Blight barons of redevelopment plot comeback – Steven Greenhut (O.C. Register): “As of February, anyway, redevelopment is dead in California, the victim of an absurdly arrogant legal and political strategy pursued by redevelopment’s chief defenders. This is wonderful news, made even better by the teeth-gnashing of public officials who have routinely abused their powers under redevelopment law. Cry me a river. But before I gloat too much, we need to remember that this victory already resembles one of those cheap horror movies where the Evil Thing has been vanquished, and all appears well, then its hand pokes out from the grave just as the credits begin.”
  • RDA Timeline: Hatchet to Fall Feb. 1 – via California Planning & Development Report: “State senators Alex Padilla and Luis Alejo have reportedly introduced Senate Bill 659, which would extend the deadline for agencies’ dissolution for several

…
Continue Reading Redevelopment Developments