Land use law

Subscribe to Land use law via RSS

Here’s the latest SCOTUS cert petition, filed by our law firm colleagues Dave Breemer and Deborah LaFetra. Because this is one of ours, we won’t be commenting, but leave it to you to digest it yourself.

Here’s the Question Presented:

Frank and Rachel Revere and David and Judith Kagan (Owners) own a duplex in Los Angeles, California, as tenants in common. The Reveres live in one unit. In 2019, the Reveres applied to the City to displace a month-to-month tenant in the other unit, so they could move in their own family members. The City denied the request, concluding the tenant was protected from eviction for a family move-in under Los Angeles’ Rent Stabilization Ordinance. The Owners sued, alleging the City’s decision forced them to suffer a physical taking of their property.

The question presented is:

Whether a law that bars termination of a tenancy, and compels the occupation…

Continue Reading New Takings Cert Petition: Yee v. Escondido And Physical Occupations

As we wrote up here, national zoning and planning expert Nolan Gray joined our U. Hawaii Land Use class (and the public) last week for a talk about whether zoning is an impediment to affordable housing in Hawaii.

Thank you to Grassroot Institute of Hawaii for recording the talk, as well as making Mr. Gray’s appearance in our classroom possible. See Grassroot’s summary of his presentation here.

If you’d prefer to just listen, try this.

Continue Reading Video: “Are Zoning Laws the Cause of Hawaii’s Housing Crisis?” With Nolan Gray

PXL_20230216_040131899.PANO
The session was recorded.
Here’s the video and audio.

Earlier this week, planner M. Nolan Gray, author of the new book, “Arbitrary Lines: How Zoning Broke the American City and How to Fix It” (Island Press 2022) joined our Land Use class at the University of Hawaii Law School to talk about zoning and housing.

The title of his talk was “Are zoning laws the cause of Hawaii’s housing crisis?” The subject matter is important, and the public was invited to join us. As you can see, there was a lot of interest in this critical topic and turnout was excellent. 

Thank you to the Grassroot Institute of Hawaii for their sponsorship of the event, and for generously getting Mr. Gray to Honolulu for his in-person appearance. It was also nice to have refreshments following class, and a chance to “talk story” (as we…

Continue Reading A National Zoning Expert Pays A Visit To The L580 Land Use Class At U. Hawaii

Screenshot 2022-11-25 at 20-00-33 Land Use Management and Control William S. Richardson School of LawThe Registrar would not accept our suggestion
to change the course description to “Dirt Law”

This spring, starting mid-January we’ve been back in a law classroom, this time at one of our law almae matres, the University of Hawaii School of Law in Honolulu.

The course is Land Use Management and Control, and we meet twice a week to earn either 3 or 4 credits (depending on how big a final paper the students want to write).

324577620_1392934454575841_4384028521446163289_n
Hey, we know that fellow…

For Hawaii law students this is an essential course whether or not they intend to become dirt lawyers after graduation. Because land use law and policy cuts across almost all other areas of practice in the 808 (being a small place where land is a scarce commodity, property plays an oversize part in shaping policy, politics, and law), every law student should be taking the class. …

Continue Reading Land Use, Hawaii Style: We’re Underway With Law 580 (Land Use) At The University Of Hawaii

40th ALI-CLE

We were eagerly anticipating 40th American Law Institute-CLE Eminent Domain and Land Valuation Litigation Conference. The 2022 Conference in Scottsdale was one of the first meetings where everyone was back in-person (and was a smashing success), but that conference was early in the game so not everyone could or would attend. But in the past year most of us got back to some semblance of “normal,” and the turnout promised to be good.

We had record registrations: with over 300 attendees, faculty, and staff signed up, things were shaping up.

Plus, we were headed to Austin, Texas. The last time we held the Conference there in 2016, we loved it so much it has been in-demand for a return visit. And this year is the debut Conference for some new planning co-chairs for both the main tracks as well as the “Condemnation 101” tracks, so the buzz for the…

Continue Reading Ice Ice Baby: A Report From The 40th ALI-CLE Eminent Domain & Land Valuation Litigation Conference, Feb 1-4, 2023, Austin

LUI

Land users: come join us online for the 36th Annual Land Use Institute. Yes, the venerable program is back again, with the usual line up of dirt law experts covering all you need to know and bringing you up to speed on the latest. Here’s the description of the program:

This Annual Land Use Institute program is designed for attorneys, professional planners, and government officials involved in land use planning, zoning, permitting, property development, conservation and environmental protection, and related litigation. It not only addresses and analyzes the state-of-the-art efforts by government to manage land use and development, but also presents the key issues faced by property owners and developers in obtaining necessary governmental approvals.

This outstanding program features:

• Preeminent faculty of practitioners and academics who provide nationwide perspective without losing sight of state-specific issues.
• Critical review and analysis of the most important new cases;
• Practice-oriented discussion…

Continue Reading We’re Remote, So It’s Easy To Join Us For The 36th Annual Land Use Institute

Screenshot 2023-02-07 at 09-17-30 Emerging Issues in Property Rights

Join our Pacific Legal Foundation colleagues Jon Houghton, Daniel Woislaw, Kady Valois, and Sam Spiegelman (moderating) tomorrow, Wednesday, February 8, 2023, at 3:00 – 4:00 p.m. ET for a free webinar, “Emerging Issues in Property Rights.”

Here’s the agenda:

Protecting private property rights has been at the heart of PLF’s work since our founding in 1973. Our view, and that of the American Founders, is that property rights are foundational to all other constitutional rights.

Our relentless defense of property rights has secured many precedented victories, including 12 property rights wins at the U.S. Supreme Court—and counting.

Unfortunately, even today, the need for property rights champions remains critical.

Government officials too often relegate property rights to second-class status among Americans’ constitutional rights—cloaking their assaults in erroneous assertions of environmental protection or cleverly constructed land use restrictions.

To learn more about property rights’ legal landscape in…

Continue Reading “Emerging Issues In Property Rights” – Wednesday, February 8, 2023, 3-4pm ET (Free!)

Screenshot 2023-01-28 at 11-23-31 Are zoning laws the cause of Hawaii’s housing crisis (Oahu)

Here’s your chance to spend some time with the author of one of the hottest land use and public policy books out there, Nolan Gray.

RSVP now (admission free, but space is limited) to join our Land Use class when we welcome Mr. Gray to respond to the question in the title of this post. Details:

Date: Wednesday, February 15, 2023

Time: 5:30pm – 7:00 pm, Hawaii Time

Location: University of Hawaii Law School (2515 Dole Street, Honolulu), Classroom #3.

Cost: Free, courtesy of Grassroot Institute of Hawaii

RSVP: You must register here to reserve your place in the room.

Parking: modest fee, available at the adjacent UH parking structure.

As we noted when we featured his book “Arbitrary Lines: How Zoning Broke the American City and How to Fix It” (Island Press 2022) at the top of our dirt lawyer holiday gift guide recently, his work…

Continue Reading Hey Honolulu, RSVP To Join Us: Nolan Gray, “Are zoning laws the cause of Hawaii’s housing crisis?” Feb 15 @5:30, U.H. Law School

If your first reaction to the Texas Court of Appeals (First District)’s decision in City of Houston v. The Commons of Lake Houston, Ltd., No. 01-21-00369-DV (Jan. 12, 2023) is scratching your head, then please come join us in bewilderment.

After all, the court held that a takings claim failed because the city is immune from inverse condemnation. Say what? We thought that the self-executing nature of the just compensation requirement of the U.S. Constitution (and the Texas Constitution) means that claims of sovereign immunity don’t hold water in inverse cases.

The Commons wants to develop “The Crossing,” one of those big master-planned communities. The usual development activities entailed: master plan, subdivision plats, city approvals for infrastructure, and even some actual site work. “By April 2018, The Commons had invested millions of dollars in planning and infrastructure for The Crossing.” Slip op. at 2.

But in…

Continue Reading An Ordinance Isn’t A Taking Because It’s A Valid Exercise Of Police Power?: What The Heck Is Going On In The Texas Court Of Appeals (First District)?

Today’s post is by our Pacific Legal Foundation colleague Kady Valois, writing about last week’s opinion by the Florida District Court of Appeal (Second District) in Lake Lincoln, LLC v. County of Manatee, No. 2D21-2826 (Jan. 13, 2023),

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

Divide and Conquer (Or Not): Florida’s Test
For The Regulatory Takings Larger Parcel

by Kady Valois

It is highly likely that anyone who follows this blog, at least as religiously as I do, groaned when the Supreme Court issued its decision in Murr v. Wisconsin, 137 S.Ct. 1933 (2017). After all, what could be more accessible and pro- private property than creating a balancing test within a balancing test and expanding the “parcel as a whole analysis” to encompass not only the regulated property but also any other property owned by the plaintiff (in the case of the Murr family, a parcel abutting the property they asserted was…

Continue Reading Guest Post – Kady Valois, “Divide (Or Not) and Conquer: Florida’s Test For The Regulatory Takings Larger Parcel”