Following the announcement that GM will be closing its Detroit-area Hamtramck assembly plant (originally a Cadillac plant), comes the reminder that it wasn’t supposed to be that way. This was the area, after all, condemned for “economic development” in the infamous Poletown case

But as the Detroit Free Press reported in “GM’s Hamtramck plant closing reopens old controversy in Detroit,” “[m]aybe the naysayers were right all along.” Yes, the Michigan Supreme Court righted the ship later, in County of Wayne v. Hathcock, 684 N.W.2d 765 (Mich. 2004), but that came too late to save the Poletown property owners.

For some commentary from someone who was there, check out Professor Gideon Kanner’s most recent post, “Bye, bye General Motors Poletown Plant,” where he writes, “This caper cost the taxpayers some $200 million and it spared GM having to pay its full tax share. It was supposed

Continue Reading Prof. Gideon Kanner: “Bye, bye General Motors Poletown Plant”

Get ready. In this and upcoming posts, we’re going to be featuring the items on our agenda for the upcoming ALI-CLE Eminent Domain and Land Valuation Litigation Conference, January 24-26, 2019, in sunny Palm Springs, California. 

ALI-CLE has released the brochure, which those of you on the mailing list should have received — or will be receiving — in your brick-and-mortar inboxes. If not, download it here. Looking it over, you will see that we have assembled a great faculty with expertise in the range of issues that are driving our branch of the law, locally and nationally.

And, as always, one of the best aspects of this conference is the collegiality. Our attendees and faculty find that one of the most beneficial parts of the conference is to meet your colleagues from across the country, and talk shop about the issues we love.  

Of course we

Continue Reading ALI-CLE Eminent Domain And Land Valuation Litigation Palm Springs Brochure Is Out

20181002_154246_HDR (1)

Last week, the 15th Annual Brigham-Kanner Property Rights Conference saw the gathering of legal scholars, judges, lawyers, and law students at the William and Mary Law School to award the B-K Property Rights Prize to Cardozo lawprof Stewart Sterk, followed by a day-long conference focusing on Professor Sterk’s work and the latest developments in property rights law.

Professor Sterk joins the pantheon of property law scholars (and a judge and a practitioner) who have been awarded the Prize. Pretty impressive:

WIN_20151002_13_15_51_Pro

As always, the program starts off with a candlelight dinner and award presentation in the historic Wren Building, definitely a highlight of the Conference. More about the Conference here

And there’s nothing like spending the following day addressing some of the most pressing issues in our area, along with the brightest minds in the business (below is the final panel of the day, with Professor John Echeverria

Continue Reading 2018 Brigham-Kanner Property Rights Conference Report: Emerging Issues

Our colleague and co-planning chair Joe Waldo was in town yesterday, so we walked through historic Williamsburg, Virginia (cradle of the Constitution and the Bill of Rights), to invite you to join us for the 36th Annual ALI-CLE Eminent Domain & Land Valuation Litigation Conference (January 24-26, 2019, in Palm Springs, California).

As we wrote in this post, the Conference will feature the nation’s best eminent domain faculty, presenting on the topics we love.

Register now here. Early registration and group discounts available. The 2018 Conference in Charleston sold out, so be sure to sign up now so you don’t miss out. Continue Reading Join Us For The 36th Annual ALI-CLE Eminent Domain & Land Valuation Litigation Conference In Palm Springs (Jan 24-26, 2019)

20180126_111558_HDR

You’ve known for a while that Palm Springs, California, specifically the Renaissance Palm Springs Hotel (a resort facility, but right in town, so you will have many options for “off campus” activities like art museums, the aerial tram, golf, and whatever suits your fancy, and close-in to the Palm Springs Airport), is the venue for our 2019 ALI-CLE Eminent Domain and Land Valuation Litigation, January 24 through 26, 2019.

Of course, you also knew that the programming would be the usual spread of topical and cutting-edge topics, presented by some of the nation’s experts. But we didn’t give you the details. So here are some of the programs we’re having: 

  • Keynote Address: “Property Rights: Foundation for a Free Society” – Taylor Revley, most recently the past President of the College of William and Mary, and also former law school Dean (as well as a


Continue Reading ALI-CLE 2019 Eminent Domain And Land Valuation Litigation Conference, Palm Springs Agenda – Register Now!

20180717_135234_HDR

Here are the cases and other items I either spoke about or mentioned at today’s Transportation Research Board‘s 57th Annual Workshop on Transportation Law in Cambridge, Massachusetts:


Continue Reading Links And Materials From Today’s Transportation Research Board Session

Here’s the amici brief we’re filing in an important Public Use case we’ve been following.

In St. Bernard Port, Harbor & Terminal District v. Violet Dock Port, Inc., No. 2017-C-0434 (Jan. 30, 2017), the Louisiana Supreme Court upheld the taking by the St. Bernard Port, Harbor, and Terminal District of a Mississippi River docking facility downriver from New Orleans. The Port took the entire VDP facility, made no change in how the property was used, and eventually turned over operation of the facility to a “hand-picked” private operator. The owner challenged the power to take, as well as the compensation awarded. We filed an amicus brief on the issue of compensation, arguing that just compensation isn’t limited to fair market value, but the jury must be allowed to consider replacement cost for a unique property like VDP’s facility. 

The Louisiana Supreme Court held that the Port has the power

Continue Reading SCOTUS Amici Brief: Kelo Revisited – Louisiana Case Is An Opportunity To Clarify Eminent Domain Pretext

This one is more for our muni law friends, but today’s post also has two eminent domain angles. 

Anyone who has been to a city council meeting knows at least one fellow like this, considered a pain-in-the-butt by officials. A gadfly, who testifies on seemingly every issue. This is Fane Lozman, eminent domain protester (among other things). Familiar to readers as the Houseboat Guy. Or, more accurately, the “Floating Home” Guy who took the City of Riviera Beach, Florida to the U.S. Supreme Court once before, on the arcane issue of whether his floating home was a houseboat subject to admiralty jurisdiction. The Court held it wasn’t, and wasn’t. 

The houseboat affair wasn’t the end of it for Mr. Lozman, who already was “an outspoken critic of the City’s plan to use its eminent domain power to seize homes along the waterfront for private development,” according to the latest

Continue Reading Arrested Eminent Domain Protester Still Can Sue City For First Amendment Violations

You might not think that the conclusion which the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit reached in M.A.K. Investment Group, LLC v. City of Glendale, No. 16-1492 (May 14, 2018) would be all that controversial: when private property is declared by a municipality to be “blighted” and subject to redevelopment (and eminent domain), the municipality needs to tell the owner about it, even if the taking may occur somewhere down the road. But apparently it was not obvious, for it took years of litigation to figure it out.

Colorado’s urban renewal statute permits local governments to designate private property as blighted (by looking at eleven factors), take it any time within the next seven years, and transfer the land to a new private owner. An owner has a very short time window — 30 days — to challenge the blight determination by filing a lawsuit in a Colorado

Continue Reading 10th Cir: When City Declares Property Blighted And Subject To Condemnation, It Must Tell The Property Owner

Here’s what we’re reading today:


Continue Reading Monday Readings: South Africa Takings, Redevelopment, Metes and Bounds, And More