Rent Control

Subscribe to Rent Control via RSS

Space is filling up, but there’s still time to join us later this month in Detroit for the 32nd Annual Land Use Institute (April-19-20). 

We’ll let program Planning Chair Frank Schnidman explain all the reasons why, and we’ll add only these points: (1) it’s a very good program that won’t take much of your time (fly in for the Thursday afternoon program, stay a night, fly home on Friday evening); (2) Detroit is the place to be these days; and (3) it’s one of the best deals in CLE credits, with tuition as low as $400.

2018 Land Use Institute Brochure Detroit 5 2018

Continue Reading There’s Still Time To Join Us In Detroit: 32d Annual Land Use Institute

2018 LUI header Detroit-1

Mark your calendars, plan to come: Detroit, April 19-20, 2018. For what is perhaps the best deal in CLE (tuition as low as $400), the 32d Annual Land Use Institute, sponsored by our section of the ABA, the Section of State and Local Government Law.

The venue is the Detroit Mercy School of Law, and the conference hotel is the historic Westin Book Cadillac in downtown Detroit. The Land Use Institute is being held in conjunction with the Section’s Spring State and Local Law Conference. Register for one conference, and you are free to move between sessions (no additional registration fees).

Planning Chairs Frank Schnidman and Dean Patrica Salkin have assembled an excellent faculty and program for the two days. Topics include: “Nuts and Bolts of Land Use Practice: Vested Rights and Regulatory Takings,” “Public-Private Partnerships,” “Climate Change and Resilient Development,” “Client…

Continue Reading 32nd Annual Land Use Institute: Detroit, April 19-20, 2018

Here is the video of last Friday’s oral arguments in a case we’ve been following, in which the owners of a mobile home park successfully challenged a California municipality’s rent control ordinance as a taking.

In Colony Cover Properties v. City of Carson, a U.S. District Court for the Central District of California jury awarded the park owner just compensation, concluding that under Penn Central, the rent control ordinance was a compensable taking. The total award to the park owner, including damages for lost rental income, attorneys’ fees, and interest, was over $9 million. As far as we can tell, this is the first case in which a mobile home park owner has succeeded in obtaining compensation for a taking for rent control.

Predictably, the city went ballistic, and its brief in the Ninth Circuit argues the City is the aggrieved party:

In April 2006, Plaintiff Colony Cove…

Continue Reading Video: Ninth Circuit Penn Central Oral Arguments

IMG_2931

University of Hawaii Law School Professor David Callies last night was presented with William and Mary Law School’s Brigham-Kanner Property Rights Prize which is “presented annually to a scholar, practitioner or jurist whose work affirms the fundamental importance of property rights.” 

As W&M notes about Professor Callies, a “prolific scholar whose work explores land use, property, and state and local government law, Callies has lectured around the world and authored or collaborated on about 90 articles and 20 books. He has been a member of the prestigious American Law Institute since 1990 and is the Benjamin A. Kudo Professor of Law at the University of Hawaiʻi at Mānoa. Prior to entering academia, he was an attorney in private practice and an assistant state’s attorney.”

IMG_3028

We’re spending today in a series of panels which explore and build upon Professor Callies’ lifetime of work. Michael Berger, a past Prize winner, kicked off…

Continue Reading Professor David Callies Awarded William & Mary Law’s Brigham-Kanner Property Rights Prize

IMG_20170126_133958

Here are the links and references to the cases we spoke about today at our opening session on the national trends in eminent domain law at the 2017 ALI-CLE Eminent Domain and Land Valuation Litigation Conference in San Diego. 

We again have a record attendance, and a good number of new attendees. If you aren’t here now, we’re sorry you didn’t make it. But fear not: ALI-CLE has already set the date and location for the 2018 Conference: save the date on your calendars now — January 25-27, 2018, Charleston, South Carolina, at the Francis Marion Hotel. 

…
Continue Reading Day 1, 2017 ALI-CLE Eminent Domain And Land Valuation Litigation Conference, San Diego

IMG_20160804_161355 (1)

We’re experiencing the madness that is the ABA Annual Meeting — this time in San Francisco — hanging with colleagues from the State and Local Government Law Section (where we’re slated to be the Chair-Elect this year), and at the Council of Appellate Lawyers. These meetings are a lot of … meetings .. but there’s also a healthy dose of CLE programming, some of it focused on things like eminent domain and land use, and other topics near and dear. 

Pictured above is our friend and colleague from the Northwest, Jamila Johnson, who gave a spirited defense of the Fifth Amendment and property rights in her session on energy corridors. We were discussing the pros and cons of “quick take” statutes, and to counter the assertion that these things allow for efficient, convenient, and cost-effective government projects, Jamila responded (and we’re recalling this from memory here), “the government has…

Continue Reading Eminent Domain Programming At The ABA Annual Meeting

20160603_075340

As we head into the weekend, one more reminder about two worthwhile eventss being staged next week: 

  • Monday, June 6, 2016: “Airbnb & Zoning: A Planner & Lawyer’s Guide to Short-Term Rentals,” with our ABA and Owners’ Counsel colleague Dwight Merriam, FAICP. From the Planning and Law Division of the American Planning Association. Details here. If issues about the “sharing economy” like AirBnB, Uber, Lyft, and similar operations, and how they work in the regulatory environment are of interest, you might want to consider joining us at the ABA: we’ve just formally launched a new group within the Section of State and Local Government Law dedicated to these pressing legal questions. Stay tuned here for a separate post on how to join us.  
  • Thursday & Friday, June 9-10, 2016: Oregon Eminent Domain Conference, Portland. We’ll be speaking at that one. The focus is on Oregon

…
Continue Reading Seminar Reminder: Oregon Eminent Domain; Sharing Economy Issues

Here’s the amici brief we filed today in California Building Industry Ass’n v. City of San Jose, No. 15-330 (Oct. 16, 2015).

That’s the case in which the California Supreme Court upheld the city’s “affordable housing” requirement against a challenge which asserted that it was an exaction and thus should have been subject to the heightened scrutiny of the unconstitutional conditions doctrine of Nollan, Dolan, and Koontz. The California court disagreed, holding that because the ordinance did not require a developer to give up land, or money in lieu of land, it was a mere zoning restriction and subject to the “rational basis” test. 

CBIA filed a cert petition, and our brief (filed on behalf of the National Federation of Independent Business Small Business Legal Center and the Owners’ Counsel of America) agrees that the Court should review this case. We argue that even though …

Continue Reading Amici Brief In SCOTUS Affordable Housing Case: Prohibiting Homebuilders From Selling At Fair Market Value For 55 Years Is A Taking

ALI-CLE-2016-masthead

Here’s the full agenda for the 2016 Eminent Domain and Land Valuation Litigation / Condemnation 101 Conference, January 28-30, 2016, in Austin, Texas. 

Together with our friend and colleague Joe Waldo, we think we’re put together a pretty good program that covers a lot of ground. This is the first time the conference has been to Austin, and we’re starting off with a talk by Austin Mayor Steve Adler, who in his former life was an eminent domain lawyer. Other highlights:

  • Professor Ilya Somin will speak about his recently-published book in a segment entitled “The Impact of Kelo and the Limits of Eminent Domain.”
  • “Pipelines and Energy Corridors: Valuation Perspectives of Condemnors and Condemnees” with the lawyers on the front lines of one of the hottest topics in eminent domain law nationwide.
  • Retired Minnesota Supreme Court Justice Paul H. Anderson will give us his tips

…
Continue Reading It’s Here – 2016 ALI-CLE Eminent Domain Conference: Complete Agenda, Faculty, Registration Information

From the Ninth Circuit, a published opinion in a case challenging a Napa Valley city’s mobilehome rent control ordinance, Rancho de Calistoga v. City of Calistoga, No. 12-17749 (Sep. 3, 2015). Here’s a complete summary of the issues in the case, along with the Ninth Circuit merits and amici briefs. We’ve been following it because we filed an amicus brief in support of the property owner’s argument that it pleaded enough to get by a motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim. 

The Ninth Circuit didn’t agree, and affirmed the District Court’s dismissal. The panel concluded the case was ripe under Williamson County (an issue that seemed to occupy a lot of the judges’ time at oral arguments), but that the owner’s theory that “even if the taking is for a public purpose, the rent subsidy should be paid by the government if the rent is…

Continue Reading Where’s Palazzolo, Ninth Circuit? Owner Bought Property Subject To Regulation (Just Not These Regulations), So Has No Takings Claim