Earlier today, I moderated a panel of expert speakers on the topic of “Civil Forfeiture of Property” at the 12th Annual Brigham-Kanner Property Rights Conference at William and Mary Law School in Williamsburg, Virginia.
Sara Sun Beale of Duke Law, Scott Bullock of the Institute for Justice, and Sandra Guerra Thompson of the University of Houston Law School were our speakers. Here are my introductory remarks:
Is the right of private property a “poor relation” to other civil rights, as the Supreme Court once warned? Or is the Takings Clause like the Pirate Code in Pirates of the Caribbean — more like what you’d call ‘guidelines’ than actual rules?
If you were to look only at civil forfeiture laws — what one of our speakers has eloquently referred to as “policing for profit” — you might think so.
These laws allow government to seize private property without first convicting or even charging



