August 2024

Screenshot 2024-08-09 at 09-59-51 Brigham-Kanner Property Rights Conference 2024 Tickets Williamsburg Eventbrite

Come join us in Williamsburg, Virginia at the William and Mary Law School for the 21st edition of the Brigham-Kanner Property Rights Conference. The Conference is unique, because its express purpose is to bring property legal scholars and property law practitioners together to discuss, what else, property and property rights law.

Yes, there’s a healthy dose of theory and academics, but also the real-world perspectives of practicing lawyers who bring the cases that put theory into practice. (New to this event and want a preview? Here’s our write-up of the 2024 Conference.)

More details here. Register here.

The days prior to the Conference launch on Thursday All that week, we’re putting on student-oriented programming.in conjunction with the WM Law Career Services Office. Sessions on “Careers in Dirt Law,” “Land Use and Real Estate Law in Practice,” and “Comparative Property Rights,” for example, presented by experienced practitioners…

Continue Reading Register Now: 21st Brigham-Kanner Property Rights Conference, William & Mary Law School, Sep. 12-13, 2024

20151205_145921

This one is a must-read.

In Darby Dev. Co., Inc. v. United States, No. 22-1929 (Aug. 7, 2024), the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit held that the Court of Federal Claims should not have dismissed Darby’s complaint for failure to state a physical invasion takings claim.

The short takeaways:

  • Takings claims do not require the government action be legally authorized (here, the courts invalidated the government action, after which the plaintiff sued for a taking), only that the government action was “authorized” and thus can be “chargeable to the government.”
  • Prohibiting evictions is not merely a regulation of the landlord-tenant relationship. Yee v. City of Escondido is distinguishable, and does not categorically exempt all actions that implicate the landlord-tenant relationship from physical takings challenge.

We think the longer story is worth your time. Here it is.

As you may recall, the Center for Disease Control purported…

Continue Reading Deepening A Lower Court Split, Fed Cir (2-1) Reinstates CDC Co-19 Eviction Moratorium Temporary Takings Claim

Check this out, the latest takings cert petition from the Pacific Legal Foundation shop.

Since this is one of ours (our colleague Chris Kieser is in the lead), we’re not going into too much detail, but will say that this involves ripeness in a regulatory takings claims, a topic we’ve been focused on a lot lately.

The question here is once the government says “no” to a development plan, must the owner keep on asking? What’s that old adage? If at first you don’t succeed, try and try again? We know that in land use, that means as long as the government says it is willing to “clarify” or “change” its decision (something it almost always asserts it is able and willing to do), most courts will very likely never hold it to task. Planning authorities know this, and as a consequence are hardwired to almost never say no…

Continue Reading New Cert Petition: After Permit Denial, To Ripen A Takings Claim Do You Have To Keep On Trying?

81XRFQ5ONQL._SL1500_

If you are in the California Southland (or plan to be in the next week), please be sure to reserve on your calendar Tuesday, August 13, 2024, to join us in-person for the launch of our colleague Jim Burling‘s forthcoming book, “Nowhere to Live: The Hidden Story of America’s Housing Crisis.”

Here’s a blurb about the book, which is available for preorder on Amazon:

A century of policy mistakes ruined America’s cities and created an unprecedented housing crisis.   
 
For many families, homelessness is no longer someone else’s problem. It is right around the corner, a real threat in their own immediate future. Our housing crisis is the result of a long history of government policies, court cases, and political manipulation. While these disparate causes make up a tangled web, they have one surprising root: the attack on private property rights. For more than…

Continue Reading Book Launch Event, Aug 13, 2024: Jim Burling, “Nowhere to Live: The Hidden Story of America’s Housing Crisis”

Screenshot 2024-07-31 at 17-33-40 The End of Means-End Scrutiny by Francesca Procaccini SSRN

Here’s an article worth reading, just posted to SSRN, Procaccini, The End of Means-End Scrutiny (July 29, 2024).

For your takings and individual liberty nerds, please focus on pages 36-38 (showing how takings analysis is not accomplished by the usual means-ends scrutiny), pages 40-42 (social and economic liberties), and pages 43-44 (searches and seizure).

Why move from means-ends scrutiny to more robust judicial review? Zero in on pages 50-52 (“Transforming Rights from Mediated Interests to Uncompromising Trumps”). We’re thinking the author concludes this move is a bad thing, but we’re not so sure it is.

Here’s the Abstract:

It is black letter law that courts apply means-end scrutiny to evaluate laws that burden constitutional rights. Not anymore. Discreetly and pervasively, this Supreme Court has ousted means-end scrutiny from constitutional law. It has done so through a series of smaller and seemingly unconnected doctrinal incursions, including the introduction of history and…

Continue Reading New Article: “The Ends of Means-Ends Scrutiny”