Floods and Flooding

Subscribe to Floods and Flooding via RSS

Alex Boone note

Check this out, a new student-authored note from William and Mary third-year law student Alex Boone, “The Tide’s Coming In: A New Case for Beachfront Property Rights in South Carolina,” 47 Wm. & Mary Envtl. L. & Pol’y Rev. 383 (2023).

Here’s the Abstract:

Part I of this Note explores the scientific data as it relates to the impending consequences of climate change on South Carolina’s coast and will introduce the disastrous scenarios that are predicted to arise as a result of rising sea levels and the accelerating strength and severity of extreme weather events. Part II compares the effectiveness of various coastal resiliency tools and highlights the regulatory framework that prohibits their use by beachfront property owners. Part III explores the topic of regulatory takings and their indirect prophylactic nature of protecting citizens from regulatory overreach and offers a case for a South Carolina court to find…

Continue Reading New Article: Alex Boone, “The Tide’s Coming In: A New Case for Beachfront Property Rights in South Carolina” (Wm & Mary Envt’ L & Pol’y Rev)

Mortons

A quick one from the Indiana Supreme Court (thanks to our Pacific Legal Foundation colleague Sam Spiegelman for the heads-up on this one).

In Town of Linden v. Birge, No. 22S-PL-352 (Mar. 7, 2023), the court held that intermittent government-induced flooding of property is treated as a permanent invasion and a per se taking if the flooding is inevitably recurring.

A Town owned and maintained drain fell into disrepair, “resulting in frequent flooding of the Town” so replacement and upgrade was in order. The Town did so and formed an improvement district to fund it. The Birge property was assessed $7k, and after some back-and-forth about the location and placement of a manhole cover on the Birge property, the upgrade project went forward. But “[a]fter completion of the project in late 2012, low-lying portions of the Birges’ Property flooded after any heavy rainfall, encumbering the Birges’ farming enterprise. So…

Continue Reading When It Rains, It Floods: Intermittent Flooding, Inevitably Recurring, Is Treated As A Permanent Invasion

There’s not a lot new to report in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit’s opinion in Kreuziger v Milwaukee County, No. 22-2489 (Feb. 13, 2023). But there’s a bit of old that make it worth posting.

The issue the court considered was whether riparian property owners have any protectable interest in the level of the water which their property abuts. After the County demolished a long-standing dam on the Milwaukee River resulting in a four-foot lowering of the water next to Kreuziger’s upriver property, he sued for a taking. Slip op. at 3 (“The lower surface level of the river exposed a ten-foot strip of marshy land between Kreuziger’s seawall and the water’s edge that had previously been submerged.”).

You probably already understand the general rule in these situations: riparian owners have no compensable property interest in any particular water level, as long as the waterway…

Continue Reading CA7: Riparian Owner Has No Property Right In Water Level On Navigable River

LUI

Here are the opinions that we spoke about this afternoon at the Land Use Institute on “The Use of Eminent Domain for Redevelopment & Economic Development Projects.”

Thanks for joining in.Continue Reading Cases And Links From Today’s Land Use Institute Session: “The Use of Eminent Domain for Redevelopment & Economic Development Projects”

40th ALI-CLE

We were eagerly anticipating 40th American Law Institute-CLE Eminent Domain and Land Valuation Litigation Conference. The 2022 Conference in Scottsdale was one of the first meetings where everyone was back in-person (and was a smashing success), but that conference was early in the game so not everyone could or would attend. But in the past year most of us got back to some semblance of “normal,” and the turnout promised to be good.

We had record registrations: with over 300 attendees, faculty, and staff signed up, things were shaping up.

Plus, we were headed to Austin, Texas. The last time we held the Conference there in 2016, we loved it so much it has been in-demand for a return visit. And this year is the debut Conference for some new planning co-chairs for both the main tracks as well as the “Condemnation 101” tracks, so the buzz for the…

Continue Reading Ice Ice Baby: A Report From The 40th ALI-CLE Eminent Domain & Land Valuation Litigation Conference, Feb 1-4, 2023, Austin

If your first reaction to the Texas Court of Appeals (First District)’s decision in City of Houston v. The Commons of Lake Houston, Ltd., No. 01-21-00369-DV (Jan. 12, 2023) is scratching your head, then please come join us in bewilderment.

After all, the court held that a takings claim failed because the city is immune from inverse condemnation. Say what? We thought that the self-executing nature of the just compensation requirement of the U.S. Constitution (and the Texas Constitution) means that claims of sovereign immunity don’t hold water in inverse cases.

The Commons wants to develop “The Crossing,” one of those big master-planned communities. The usual development activities entailed: master plan, subdivision plats, city approvals for infrastructure, and even some actual site work. “By April 2018, The Commons had invested millions of dollars in planning and infrastructure for The Crossing.” Slip op. at 2.

But in…

Continue Reading An Ordinance Isn’t A Taking Because It’s A Valid Exercise Of Police Power?: What The Heck Is Going On In The Texas Court Of Appeals (First District)?

We really want you there…

One (nearly) last reminder that there’s still time to register for your space at the 40th ALI-CLE Eminent Domain & Land Valuation Litigation Conference, February 1-4, 2023, in Austin. In the past several years, we have sold out due to the conference room capacity and the conference hotel block. But there’s still space, although we are nearly full. So register now – don’t delay any further! 

Here’s the brochure with the complete agenda, schedule, and faculty listing. But to tempt you, here are some of the highlights of the program:

  • Everything Old is New Again: Why Today’s Practitioners Need to Understand the Original Meaning of the Takings and Just Compensation Clauses
  • When the SWAT Team Comes (No) Knocking: Police Power Takings

  • Private Utility Takeovers – Lessons From a 67 Day Trial

  • “Contraband”: How Property Rights Helped Pave the Way for Civil Rights

  • Valuation

…
Continue Reading (Nearly) Last Call: There’s Still Time To Join Us For The 40th ALI-CLE Eminent Domain & Land Valuation Litigation Conference, Feb 1-4, Austin

Due to our 808 roots, we’ve been fielding a lot of questions related to the ongoing eruption of Mauna Loa on the Big Island.

It’s big, it’s spectacular (see video above), and (for us) it’s law.

The questions (who owns “accreted” lava?, how does the NPS let the public out to see this?, what uses can be made of property covered by lava?) made us realize that we had addressed some of those issues in prior posts. So we’re reposting:

Hope you find useful these things that make Hawaii property law pretty interesting at times.Continue Reading Law Of The Lava – Who Owns New “Accreted” Land? (And Other Questions)

Here it is, the official agenda and program for the 40th ALI-CLE Eminent Domain & Land Valuation Litigation Conference, February 2-4, 2023 (with a special event the evening of Wednesday, February 1, 2023 to entice you to arrive early).

Screenshot 2022-11-18 at 13-35-13 ALI CLE PA NY VA TX FL Continuing Legal Education

Here’s the brochure with the complete agenda, schedule, and faculty listing. But to tempt you, here are some of the highlights of the program:

  • Everything Old is New Again: Why Today’s Practitioners Need to Understand the Original Meaning of the Takings and Just Compensation Clauses

  • Private Utility Takeovers – Lessons From a 67 Day Trial

  • Valuation Issues When Billboards and Signs are Condemned

  • Setting Client Expectations and Identifying Red Flags

  • Developing Property Right Issues in Texas – Questions and Answers from the Bench: A View From the Bench (with Texas Supreme Court Justice Jimmy Blacklock)

  • Eminent Domain and Regulatory Takings Updates: Important Decisions You Need to Know

  • Ethics:

…
Continue Reading Here’s The Program For The 40th ALI-CLE Eminent Domain & Land Valuation Litigation Conference, Feb 1-4, 2023, Austin

Ideker Farms, Inc. v. United States, No. 21-1849

As written up in the FedCircuitBlog (a must-follow for all you federal takings mavens):

It concerns the federal government’s liability for taking private property. Specifically, in this case, the Federal Circuit will review the conclusion of the Court of Federal Claims that the government’s action was the cause-in-fact of flooding damage and that, as a result, a taking-by-flooding occurred. The government appeals the CFC’s judgment, while Ideker Farms cross-appeals.

Behrens v. United States, No. 22-1277

Also from the FedCircuitBlog:

Behrens v. United States, which concerns a claim the federal government was liable for taking land for public use through the National Trails System Act. Specifically, in this case, the Federal Circuit will review the determination by the Court of Federal Claims that the plaintiffs were not entitled to compensation because the scope of the easement in question was broad…

Continue Reading CAFED Hears Arguments In Two Takings Cases