Just Compensation | Appraisal

Subscribe to Just Compensation | Appraisal via RSS

Screenshot 2023-05-08 at 22-48-29 Post Feed LinkedIn

Missed out on the 2023 ALI-CLE Eminent Domain and Land Valuation Litigation Conference back in February in Austin, and the legendary “Condemnation 101” track?

Well, here’s your chance to get the knowledge. On May 18, 2023, ALI-CLE is going live with a rebroadcast of that program, including real-time Q & A with the program Planning Co-Chairs.

As we’ve noted before, the Condemnation 101 program is a great “basic training” program for lawyers new to the eminent domain and takings practice. But it is also a fantastic refresher course for those experienced dirt lawyers looking to brush up on the fundamentals.

CLE credits are available, of course. And unlike the in-person program back in February, there’s no danger of ice storm delays!

More about the program here, including registration information, fees, the agenda, and the faculty. And, just because you are a reader of this…

Continue Reading Condemnation 101: Preparing & Presenting an Eminent Domain Case Webcast (May 18, 2023)

1992 Aerial Photo Island2
Shands Key, with the City of Marathon in the background

This just in: in Shands v. City of Marathon, No. 3D21-1987 (May 3, 2023), Florida’s Third District Court of Appeals held that the city’s downzoning the property (Shands Key, shown above in an exhibit from the Key West trial we participated in in June 2021) from General Use (density: one home per acre) to Conservation Offshore Island (one home per 10 acres; Shands Key is just under 8 acres) effected a Lucas taking.

We’re not going to go into too much detail, because this case is one of ours. Our Pacific Legal Foundation colleague Jeremy Talcott was the lead trial and appellate counsel, backed by Kady Valois.

Shandstrialteam_after
Trial (and appeal) team after closing arguments in Key West:
Valois, inversecondemnation.com, Talcott

But we’re not going to let you go without noting a few highlights from the Court of…

Continue Reading This Just In – Florida Appeals Court: TDRs, Beekeeping, And Camping Are Not Economically-Beneficial Uses, So Downzoning Is A Lucas Taking

Take a deep dive into the arguments and amicus briefs

This Wednesday, April 26, 2023, the U.S. Supreme Court will hear oral arguments in Tyler v. Hennepin County, No. 22-166, our law firm’s case which argues that Hennepin County’s keeping the excess value in Ms. Tyler’s home over what she owed in property taxes and fees, is an uncompensated taking of private property, and also violates the Excessive Fines Clause.

Here are links to programs, summaries, and events to help you understand the arguments and issues, as well as registration for post-argument analysis:

…
Continue Reading Get Ready For SCOTUS Takings Arguments (Wednesday, April 26, 2023)

HAWSCT-1

Update: the court has rescheduled the arguments to June 22, 2023, at 10 a.m.

The Hawaii Supreme Court has scheduled oral arguments in an important eminent domain case about severance damages for the Honolulu Rail Authority’s condemnation of land in Honolulu for one of its stations (assuming, of course, that the under-construction rail line actually gets past downtown, or simply stops where its historic predecessor, the Oahu Railway terminated more than a century ago).

Here’s the details and the court’s description of the issues (scroll to the bottom), from the Hawaii Judiciary’s web site.

[Barista’s note: we won’t be commenting on this one in detail, because this was our case when we were in private practice.]

Thursday May 18, 2023 – 10 a.m.

NOS.

SCAP-22-0000335 (Consolidated with Nos. SCAP-22-0000336,
SCAP-22-0000337, SCAP-22-0000338, SCAP-22-0000340,
SCAP-22-0000341, SCAP-22-0000343 SCAP-22-0000344,
SCAP-22-0000345, AND SCAP-22-0000352)

SCAP-22-0000335, SCAP-22-0000336, SCAP-22-0000337,
SCAP-22-0000340, SCAP-22-0000341, SCAP-22-0000343,
SCAP-22-0000344, AND SCAP-22-0000345

…
Continue Reading Hawaii Supreme Court To Hear Major Severance Damages Appeal In Rail Takings Cases

Screenshot 2023-04-20 at 19-13-52 Condemnation 101 2023 Preparing and Presenting an Eminent Domain Case ALI CLE

Missed out on the 2023 ALI-CLE Eminent Domain and Land Valuation Litigation Conference back in February in Austin, and the legendary “Condemnation 101” track?

Well, here’s your chance to get the knowledge. On May 18, 2023, ALI-CLE is going live with a rebroadcast of that program, including real-time Q & A with the program Planning Co-Chairs.

As we’ve noted before, the Condemnation 101 program is a great “basic training” program for lawyers new to the eminent domain and takings practice. But it is also a fantastic refresher course for those experienced dirt lawyers looking to brush up on the fundamentals.

CLE credits are available, of course. And unlike the in-person program back in February, there’s no danger of ice storm delays!

More about the program here, including registration information, fees, the agenda, and the faculty. And, just because you are a reader of this…

Continue Reading Condemnation 101 (2023), Redux

PXL_20230414_184043420
Good crowd.

Here are the cases and other materials we spoke about on Friday at the 22d Annual Texas Eminent Domain Conference, in Austin. A big thank you to the Planning Chairs and to our friends at CLE International for the speaking invite.

The other cases discussed are in your materials!

PXL_20230415_011347576
The nearby Caldwell County Courthouse. A classic.

PXL_20230414_190735641
Why did no one tell me that Jabba’s Palace is in Austin?Continue Reading Links And Materials From The 22d Annual Texas Eminent Domain Conference

D Callies Retirement Celebration Invite 4-27-2023.f

Come join us on Thursday, April 27, 2023, from 5-7pm, downtown Honolulu, to celebrate the retirement of Professor David L. Callies from the University of Hawaii Law School.

Join U.H. Law School Dean Camille Nelson, Professor Callies’ colleagues, his students (present and former), the Hawaii legal community, and family and friends as we honor 43 years of scholarship, teaching, service, and practice.

Professor Callies is a prolific scholar and author, and has mentored generations of lawyers. Known especially for his work in property, land use, takings, administrative law, and state and local government law, he has also been presented with numerous awards including William and Mary’s Brigham-Kanner Property Rights Prize, and the Owner’s Counsel of America’s Crystal Eagle. 

Invitation and how to RSVP (or click below). Space is limited, so please let us know you are attending as soon as you can.

Details:

Thursday, …

Continue Reading April 27, 2023, 5-7pm, Honolulu: Join Us To Celebrate The Work And Career Of Professor David Callies

Screenshot 2023-04-04 at 09-45-09 Information - Texas Eminent Domain Conference

If you are in the Austin area (or anywhere in Texas for that matter), please consider joining us April 13 and 14, 2023 for the 22d Annual Texas Eminent Domain Conference.

Two days of great programming and talking shop, plus a chance to connect and re-connect with friends and colleagues. And, of course, all the things Austin has to offer. Yes were were there not that long ago, but come on…Austin is a great conference venue, right?

We’re speaking about “National Eminent Domain and Takings Trends,” and the balance of the program is pretty darn good also (see here or below for the full agenda).

Registration ongoing, but space is filling up fast so don’t miss out.

See you there.

Agenda & Program, 22d Annual Texas Eminent Domain Conference (CLE Int’l), Austin, Apr. 13-14, 2023)

Continue Reading Join Us At The 22d Annual Texas Eminent Domain Conference, April 13-14, Austin

As part of the nationwide reaction to Kelo v. New London, Indiana adopted a statute that in some cases requires the condemnor to compensate property owners at not just fair market value, but at 150% of FMV.

As far as we can tell, the Indiana Court of Appeals’ opinion in Guzzo v. Town of St. John, No. 21A-PL-2213 (Jan. 19, 2023) is the first appellate case applying that statute, or any similar law. Read on.

The statute at issue, Ind. Code § 32-24-4.5-8, sets compensation for the taking of “residential property” at 1.5x the fair market value:

Sec. 8. (a) Notwithstanding IC 32-24-1, a condemnor that acquires a parcel of real property through the exercise of eminent domain under this chapter shall compensate the owner of the parcel as follows:

….

(2) Subject to subsection (b), for residential property:

(A) payment to the owner equal to one hundred fifty…

Continue Reading Indiana App: This House Is “Residential Property” Qualifying It For The Statutory 150% FMV Enhancement

Screenshot 2023-02-21 at 09-24-48 Search - Supreme Court of the United States

Most of the time these days, we’re rooting for cert granted. That comes, naturally, from our work pushing cases and issues up to the Supreme Court, looking to correct lower court errors and in the process make some good law. And that usually entails being on the “petitioner” side of things. Cases like Sackett, Wilkins, and Tyler, for example.

But not always. In Financial Oversight & Management Board for Puerto Rico v. Cooperative de Ahorro y Credito Abraham Rosa, No. 22-367, we were on the “respondent” side of things, advocating for a “cert denied” because there, the First Circuit had reached what we think was the right result for the right reasons. As we noted in this post, the First Circuit correctly held that the “Fifth Amendment precludes the impairment or discharge of prepetition claims for just compensation in Title III bankruptcy.”

In short, just…

Continue Reading Cert Denied In Self-Executing Just Compensation Case