Zoning & Planning

Subscribe to Zoning & Planning via RSS

IMG_3082

This fall, I’ll be teaching a new course at the William and Mary Law School in Williamsburg, Virginia.

Here’s the description of Property Rights: Law and Theory (Law 608) from the course catalog:

Property rights and property theory have been essential components of Anglo-American law for centuries, and the protection of the right of private property ownership is one of the foundations on which the U.S. Constitution, the Bill of Rights, and the post-Civil War Amendments are built. In more recent times, however, property law has taken on a new role, and has been viewed differently than in the past, especially in light of the development of environmental law and the evolving concept of public trust.

Property Rights Law and Theory will focus on the history, policy, and, to some extent, the politics of property law, property rights, and related legal topics. We will examine how the right of…

Continue Reading The Paper Chase Is On!

Emotionheader

Here’s the printable brochure with the details on the 32nd Annual Land Use Institute in Detroit, April 19-20, 2018. We’ve plugged the program before so we won’t do so again, except to say that you really should attend because (1) it’s a very good program that won’t take much of your time (fly in for the Thursday afternoon program, stay a night, fly home on Friday evening); (2) Detroit is the place to be these days; and (3) it’s one of the best deals in CLE credits, with tuition as low as $400.

2018 Land Use Institute Brochure Detroit 5 2018

Continue Reading April 19-20, 2018: Land Use Institute, Detroit (Printable Brochure)

For those of you who have not recently attended the ALI-CLE Eminent Domain and Land Valuation Litigation Conference (just wrapped in Charleston, planning Palm Springs 2019), here’s a small sampling of the kind of thing we do.

It’s U. Virginia lawprof Molly Brady talking about the U.S. Supreme Court’s regulatory takings decision in Murr v. Wisconsin, in the session she shared with John Groen (the Murrs’ Supreme Court counsel). A really informative session, and these clips only give a small taste. More here, from ALI-CLE, including links to the on-demand video sessions we recorded in Charleston.  

And it’s not too early to mark your calendars for Palm Springs, January 24-26, 2019. Stay tuned here for further details as they become available. 

Continue Reading Professor Molly Brady On Murr – Video Clips From The ALI-CLE Eminent Domain Conference

The last time the U.S. Supreme Court faced Williamson County in a merits case, the property owners made the mistake of not challenging that case’s “state procedures” requirement directly. An exchange with Justice O’Connor went like this; from the transcript:

Justice O’Connor: And you haven’t asked us to revisit that Williamson County case, have you?

Mr. Utrecht: We have not asked that this Court reconsider the decision in Williamson County.

Justice O’Connor: Maybe you should have.

Ouch.

But fool me once, shame on you; fool me twice…we won’t get fooled again!

This time, therefore, no mistake: the owners raised a challenge to Williamson County squarely, and as a result, there may now be a light at the end of the very bizarre ripeness tunnel that has mostly kept federal courts from reviewing claims that the U.S. Constitution has been violated.

This morning, the Court agreed to hear a case…

Continue Reading New Cert Grant: Overrule Williamson County’s Exhaustion Of State Procedures Requirement?

ZPLR front page

Here’s an article (“Murr v. Wisconsin: The Supreme Court Rewrites Property Rules in Multiple-Parcel Regulatory Takings Cases“), which we authored along with a colleague, published in February 2018’s Zoning and Planning Law Report, about the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in Murr v. Wisconsin, the case about the “larger parcel” in regulatory takings.

As you might predict, we concluded that the Murr majority’s analysis was vague, unsatisfying, and generally not helpful. Strong letter to follow!

Here’s a passage from the Introduction:

The U.S. Supreme Court’s 5-3 long-anticipated ruling in Murr v. Wisconsin, expected to resolve the “larger parcel” or “denominator” issue in regulatory takings cases, has instead created a test that neither property owners, lawyers, nor government officials can understand or rely on.

The majority opinion, authored by Justice Anthony Kennedy, addressed a long-standing question in regulatory takings law: when a claimant who owns more…

Continue Reading New Article: Murr And Other “Blurred Lines”

2018 LUI header Detroit-1

Mark your calendars, plan to come: Detroit, April 19-20, 2018. For what is perhaps the best deal in CLE (tuition as low as $400), the 32d Annual Land Use Institute, sponsored by our section of the ABA, the Section of State and Local Government Law.

The venue is the Detroit Mercy School of Law, and the conference hotel is the historic Westin Book Cadillac in downtown Detroit. The Land Use Institute is being held in conjunction with the Section’s Spring State and Local Law Conference. Register for one conference, and you are free to move between sessions (no additional registration fees).

Planning Chairs Frank Schnidman and Dean Patrica Salkin have assembled an excellent faculty and program for the two days. Topics include: “Nuts and Bolts of Land Use Practice: Vested Rights and Regulatory Takings,” “Public-Private Partnerships,” “Climate Change and Resilient Development,” “Client…

Continue Reading 32nd Annual Land Use Institute: Detroit, April 19-20, 2018

Here’s one from the Hawaii Intermediate Court of Appeals, Cervelli v. Bufford, No. CAAP-13-896 (Feb. 23, 2018), in which the court considered whether homeowners who rented out rooms in their home to the public, but refused to do so to a lesbian couple, violated Hawaii’s public accommodation laws, or were sheltered from the statute by the Free Exercise Clause and other constitutional provisions.

In short, the court held they could be held liable, even though it is their home, first concluding that renting out a room in your home qualifies as offering a public accommodation, even though it is your residence. The owners advertise and offer rooms to the general public on their website and through third-party websites, rent to a large number of people (up to 200 nights per year), and pretty much takes all comers “aside from same-sex couples and smokers.” Slip op. at 11.

The potential…

Continue Reading HAWICA: Vacation Rental Home Is “Public Accommodation,” And Can’t Discriminate Based On Sexual Orientation

Sketch

Here’s the (draft) article from our poriton of the first panel at the 2017 Brigham-Kanner Conference, “Back to the Future of Land Use Regulation.” (Also posted on SSRN here.)

This is an expanded version of our talk (listen to the audio here) during the Conference during which the William and Mary Law School awarded U. Hawaii lawprof David Callies the Brigham-Kanner Prize. Our summary of the conference is posted here.

We were part of the panel entitled “The Future of Land Regulation and a Tribute to David Callies,” along with Professors Shelly Saxer and Jim Ely, and past B-K Prize winner Michael Berger. Professor Callies also delivered his opening remarks during this session.

This article has been submitted to the Brigham-Kanner Property Conference Journal which should be published later this year. 

Back to the Future of Land Use Regulation (draft Feb 11, 2018) Continue Reading Back to the Future of Land Use Regulation – Brigham-Kanner Article

Urban_lawyer3.jpg.imagep.980x179

For you land-users out there, be sure to check your inboxes for the link to the latest issue of The Urban Lawyer, the law review published by my section of the ABA, the Section of State and Local Government Law. With articles on privacy and public real estate records, neighborhood opposition to zoning changes, greenhouse gas regulation, planned communities, land use and cannabis, RLUIPA, and more.

If you are not a member of our Section, you really should be because in addition to a subscription to UL, you get to hang with a crew of lawyers, judges, and legal scholars who are smart, fun, and generous with their time. See this post for more on the reasons you should join us.

Want to see what we’re all about? Plan on joining us for our next in-person conference, the 32d Annual Land Use Institute and Spring State and Local …

Continue Reading Latest Issue Of The Urban Lawyer

Our upcoming American Law Institute-CLE Eminent Domain and Land Valuation Litigation Conference in Charleston, South Carolina has SOLD OUT our in-person registrations. 

We will have a record attendance (with over 100 first-time attendees) and the conference hotel has informed us that we can fit no more people in the meeting rooms. We cannot remember this happening before, but it tells us that we will have an energizing and exciting conference. 

Thank you to all of you who signed up and are coming or joining in online for the webcast — we’ll see you soon at the “four corners of the law.”

And if you delayed too long in registering, please don’t despair. You can still attend from home or the office because ALI has set up a live webcast of the sessions. Go here for more on how to sign up to attend by webcast.

And stay…

Continue Reading ALI-CLE Eminent Domain & Land Valuation Conference – In-Person Registration SOLD OUT (But You Can Still Join By Live Webcast)