Municipal & Local Govt law

Subscribe to Municipal & Local Govt law via RSS

A short one from the Ninth Circuit on a topic that we keep revisiting, whether the various eviction moratoria adopted and enforced by the feds and many states and local governments during Co-19.

We keep revisiting the topic because the courts keep getting it wrong.

And before we go on, a disclosure: this is one of ours, and our law firm and our colleague Jon Houghton rep the property owners.

This moratorium is from the State of Washington (yes, the same State of Washington whose moratorium was recently challenged unsuccessfully in the state courts). But this challenge is to the City of Seattle’s moratorium, and is in federal court.

Thus, it was the Ninth Circuit considering the question of whether, by commandeering rental property as pandemic public housing, Washington was on the hook for just compensation. Requiring to house residents — whatever the reason — is a physical…

Continue Reading CA9: No Physical Commandeering In Eviction Moratorium Because Yee Says “You Let The Tenants In, So You Can’t Complain About Keeping Them (For Free)”

HSBA 10-2023

Yesterday, during the Annual Meeting of the Hawaii State Bar Association, we participated in a program sponsored by the Real Property and Financial Services Section, “Inverse Condemnation & Paying for Disasters.”

As you can see above, we joined lawprofs Shelley Saxer and David Callies to share thoughts about inverse claims, and the difference between these property arguments and tort negligence claims.

Here are some of the key cases and materials which we mentioned (or should have):

…
Continue Reading Links And Materials From “Inverse Condemnation & Paying for Disasters”

In Van Sant & Co. v. Town of Calhan, No. 22-1190 (Oct. 13, 2023), the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit considered the claim of the operator of a mobile home park who asserted a due process property right to instead use its property as a RV park. Here’s why the court said no.

Van Sant was using its property as a mobile home park. It decided to use its land instead as a RV park. Turns out that the local municipality doesn’t much care for RV parks — or at least the way that Van Sant was going to use its property — so the Town shifted from a regime that didn’t regulate RV parks to a regime that prohibited or tightly controlled RV parks on certain lands (lands that looked an awful lot like Van Sant’s). And to cap it off, the Town’s new regulations…

Continue Reading CA10: Absence Of Restrictions On Land Uses Isn’t A Due Process Property Right

Here’s the latest in a case and an issue we’ve been following.

Recall that the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas concluded that the City of McKinney, Texas was liable for the taking of Vicki Baker’s home, after city police officers destroyed a large part of it while apprehending a suspect who had taken refuge therein. The court awarded just compensation and the city appealed.

Now, the other shoe drops: in Baker v. City of McKinney, No. 22-40644 (Oct. 11, 2023), the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit reversed, concluding that because the invasion was necessary and a justified use of the city’s police powers, it does not owe compensation.

We’ve been down this path before, so we won’t go over it in detail (recall that the Tenth Circuit reached the same conclusion and the subsequent cert petition was denied by the Supreme…

Continue Reading Fifth Circuit Kicks Down The SWAT Takings Door (And Boots The Issue Upstairs)

Here’s what we’re reading about the Supreme Court’s property rights docket — some good, some disappointing — this day.

  • Niina Farah, “Supreme Court flooding case could ripple across the energy sector“ (E & E News / Energywire) – About the Devillier case (which we summarized here), in which we were quoted: “The Supreme Court decision to hear the Devillier case comes after a concerted effort in recent years to convince the court to address procedural maneuvers that have made it challenging for property owners to bring their claims to court, said Robert Thomas, director of property rights litigation at the Pacific Legal Foundation. The nonprofit is among the groups that has asked the court to address takings cases and has lent its support for the property owners in Devillier in a ‘friend of the court‘ brief. ‘There’s a lot of gamesmanship going on

…
Continue Reading Supreme Court Property Rights Round-Up

Why is it, you ask, that the ALI-CLE Eminent Domain & Land Valuation Litigation Conference (scheduled next February 1-3, 2024, in New Orleans) is an event that seems to be growing in popularity and attendance. In recent years, we have standing room only in the Conference halls, and have sold out the hotel block. After all, this is a pretty niche area of law. So what gives?

When we were in Austin earlier this year, we thought it might be nice to try and answer that question. We asked Conference participants why they come, year-after-year (and in Austin, despite massive travel disruptions). Yes, it is the various venues (Nashville, Austin, Scottsdale, Palm Springs, to name a few recent locations), and yes, it is the excellent and useful programming.

But as we suspected it is more than that. As the above video notes…

Continue Reading ALI-CLE’s Eminent Domain & Land Valuation Litigation Conference (Feb 1-3, 2024, New Orleans): Why Attend? Here’s Why.

This is one of ours — argued by our Pacific Legal Foundation colleague Kady Valois — so we won’t be offering any commentary.

But we just have to post the U.S. Court of Appeals’ opinion in Iten v. County of Los Angeles, No. 22-55480 (Aug. 30, 2023), because it discusses two significant issues, and sets out a roadmap for how to successfully plead a Contracts Clause claim.

First, standing. The court held that a commercial property owner — a retired auto mechanic who leased his premises to an auto repair shop — has Article III standing to challenge the County’s commercial eviction moratorium which prevented the owner from evicting the tenant when it stopped paying rent but did not vacate. The court distinguished the standing requirement of “demonstrating injury in fact” from the question of whether the plaintiff has actually been injured. The first is a pleading requirement and…

Continue Reading CA9: Property Owner Has Standing To Challenge Commercial Eviction Moratorium Under Contracts Clause

Screenshot Capture - 2023-08-18 - 08-32-14
Where you can build 1-4 family residences by right

The Hawaii Zoning Atlas project has announced publication of the Hawaii Zoning Atlas, an “interactive map [that] explores how restrictive zoning laws can make it difficult to build diverse, affordable housing.”

The official announcement notes:

The map is based on an original dataset compiled by over 30 students [including some of our U.H. Law students!] and volunteers who combed nearly a thousand pages of regulations to extract key policy details, including whether housing units are legally allowed in an area and how many; restrictions on height, yards, and lot coverage; and parking requirements. All in all, more than 100 data points were collected for each zone in three counties–Honolulu, Maui, and Hawaiʻi. Kauaʻi will be available in a future release.

This is designed for people who are not land use insiders, to help understand how land use regulations restrict…

Continue Reading “Zoning is the most important local law you’ve never heard of” – Hawaii Zoning Atlas Published

Untitled Extract Pages

Two years ago, Owners’ Counsel of America endowed a scholarship in the name of its founder, property rights advocate and trial lawyer Toby Prince Brigham (1934-2021). The scholarship is for a second- or third- year law student to attend the annual three-day ALI-CLE Eminent Domain and Land Valuation Litigation Conference (the upcoming Conference will be in New Orleans, Louisiana, February 1-3, 2024).

The Conference affords the Scholar an all-expenses-covered opportunity to meet and network with leading property rights and eminent domain lawyers from across the country, while also learning about property law and practice. 

Here’s the official description from OCA:  

In honor of Toby’s legacy of professionalism and achievement, in 2021 OCA established the Toby Prince Brigham OCA Scholarship to pay for all expenses of a second or third year law student to attend the ALI-CLE Eminent Domain conference and associated OCA events held annually in January. This unique…

Continue Reading Owners’ Counsel Toby Prince Brigham Scholarship – Applications Being Accepted

PXL_20230426_222217568
(Tip for applicants: understanding the symbology of the
Law School’s logo will show you know the score.)

Here’s your chance to teach Property and Land Use in what might be most interesting venue on Planet Earth for those subjects: the University of Hawaii School of Law has put out a call for applications for a tenured lawprof (along with six other openings in other subjects):

The University of Hawaiʻi at Mānoa, William S. Richardson School of Law seeks to fill up to seven tenured or tenure – track positions . For doctrinal faculty, we are seeking to fill positions in Constitutional Law (tenured or tenure – track) and Property /Land Use (tenured). We welcome candidates who, in addition to one of those two fields, have expertise in Administrative Law, Business and Commercial Law, Environmental Law, Family Law, Health Law, Intellectual Property, Labor and Employment Law, Native Hawaiian Law…

Continue Reading Live The Dream! Teach Dirt Law In Hawaii: UH Law School Looking For Property & Land Use Lawprof