Penn Central

Subscribe to Penn Central via RSS

Screenshot 2022-09-13 at 14-12-11 Feed LinkedIn

One last reminder that there’ still time to register for the upcoming Brigham-Kanner Property Rights Conference at the William and Mary Law School in Williamsburg, Virginia, September 29-30, 2022. If you can’t make it to the historic campus, there’s an option to attend remotely.

In our opinion, the Conference is the best of its kind because it brings together legal scholars and the practicing bar to talk dirt law theory and practice. We also a have a full supplemental program for law students, that covers property law and careers in eminent domain law, a recruiting session, a program on international property rights, and a program on land use law.

Registration for the Conference is ongoing, and you can sign up here.

Here is the full agenda. (We’ll be speaking on Panel #2, “Reshaping the Framework Protecting Property Under the Roberts Court.”)

Come on, join us!

Continue Reading Still Time To Join Us (In-Person Or Remote) For The 19th Annual Brigham-Kanner Property Rights Conference

A short one (unpublished) from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, considering an issue we’ve been following: what is the effect of the government’s claim that it is regulating property for what looks like a valid “police power” purpose?

As noted, that’s a road we’ve been down before. Here’s a sampling:

In Bojicic v. Dewine, No. 21-4123 (Aug. 22, 2022), the Sixth Circuit was considering a takings and due process challenge to the governor’s Co-19 shutdown orders. The court rejected the district court’s rationale…

Continue Reading CA6: No “Police Power” Exception To Takings (But It’s Nonetheless Dispositive As Penn Central’s Character)

BK 2022

There’s still space for you to join us — preferably in-person, but remotely if that is not possible for you — at the 19th Annual Brigham-Kanner Property Rights Conference, September 29-30, 2022, at the William and Mary Law School in Williamsburg.

The American Law Institute was kind enough to post a notice about the Conference and the ALI members who are on the speaking faculty here.

Registration for the Conference is ongoing, and you can sign up here. Here is the full agenda. (We’ll be speaking on Panel #2, “Reshaping the Framework Protecting Property Under the Roberts Court.”

In our opinion, the Conference is the best of its kind, and brings together legal scholars and the practicing bar to talk dirt law. So please come join us.Continue Reading Registration Underway – 19th Annual Brigham-Kanner Property Rights Conference (Sep 29-30, 2022)

You’ll definitely want to check out the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit’s opinion in Makrilov v. City of Jersey City, No. 21-1786 (Aug. 16, 2022).

Not because it reaches any earth-shattering conclusions — the opinion unsurprisingly concluded that the city’s restricting (but not eliminating) short-term rentals (less than thirty days) was not a taking — but primarily because of the interesting concurring opinion.

So here’s the story. At one time, the city thought that renting residential property for less than thirty days was a good thing, believing that short-term renting “incentivize[d] investment and development in Jersey City.” Slip op. at 3. The city even adopted an ordinance affirmatively legalizing STRs as permitted accessory uses in residential zones. A property owner didn’t even need to obtain a permit, as long as the operation was small-scale (the owner did not have more than five units it rented).

But…

Continue Reading Penn Central May Be A “Fuzzy” Test, But What Is A Court Doing Weighing The Factors?

Today’s a busy day, so we can’t lay out the details of the Texas Court of Appeals’ opinion in City of Dallas v. Trinity East Energy, LLC, No. 05-20-00550-DV (Aug. 1, 2022). But we want to post up the decision and urge you to read it because it is a rare bird: not only did the property owner win a takings claim at trial – the verdict survived appellate review.

The takings claims (Lucas and Penn Central) were based on the city’s denial of a Special Use Permit. The city argued that its denial of the SUP for the desired drilling locations did not cut off completely the owner’s ability to access the minerals, since there were other ways to get at them. Here’s what happened at trial:

The trial court found that other than the drill sites proposed in Trinity’s three SUP requests, “Trinity did not…

Continue Reading Tex App: Property Owner’s Penn Central Verdict For Drilling Permit Denial Is OK By Us

IRWA

The International Right of Way Association‘s Real Estate Law Committee produces twice-a-year reports “which contain summaries of eminent domain decisions and legislation within the United States.”

And what is really nice is that they make the report available. 

We’re posting it here because we’re one of the co-authors. Hat tip to our co-authors Brad Kuhn, Jillian Friess Leivas, and Ajay Gajaria.

The report is short, and doesn’t contain a lot of fluff. Just what you wanted.Continue Reading IRWA’s Summary Of Major Eminent Domain Cases & Legislation (Jan-May 2022)

Screenshot 2022-07-07 at 13-44-38 The Brigham-Kanner Property Rights Conference

By now, you know that the 19th Brigham-Kanner Property Rights Conference is set for September 29-30, 2022, at the William and Mary Law School in Williamsburg, Virginia (register here – space is limited – fee ranges from free to $195 – a bargain!). And you know that our colleague Jim Burling is this year’s B-K Prize winner.

But now you know who is speaking at the Conference, and the topics: here’s the full agenda. The list of speakers is too long to list here but check out these topics:

  • Panel 1: The Importance of Property Rights: A Tribute to James S. Burling
  • Panel 2: Reshaping the Framework Protecting Property Under the Roberts Court (that’s the panel we’re speaking on)
  • Roundtable: Emerging Issues in Takings and Property Rights Litigation
  • Panel 3: Choosing A Property Regime
  • Panel 4: Property Rights in Times of Scarcity and Crisis

Who can …

Continue Reading Here’s The Full Speaker And Topic List For The Brigham-Kanner Property Rights Conference (Sep 29-30, 2022)

Here’s what we’re reading today:

Continue Reading Monday Round Up: Aina Lea Out With A Whimper, 30 Years Of Mabo, Seneca Village

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit’s decision in Nowlin v. Pritzker, No. 21-1279 (May 20, 2022), adds to a long line of rulings denying takings claims for coronavirus-related business shutdowns. 

This one challenged the Illinois governor’s executive orders which required “non-essential” businesses to shut down or reduce operations, and limited the size of gatherings. The plaintiffs brought the usual host of constitutional claims (a total of six), which included (naturally) a takings claim. The district court, after granting leave to allow the filing of an amended complaint, dismissed all six claims, concluding either that the plaintiffs had not alleged particularized injuries (and thus lacked standing, and thus the court lacked jurisdiction), or that the complaint failed to state claims.

The Seventh Circuit affirmed that all claims, with the exception of the takings claims, lacked jurisdiction because the plaintiffs had not alleged specific injuries. The court subject…

Continue Reading CA7: Co-19 Shutdown Complaint Does Not Meet “Demanding test for alleging a regulatory taking”

In FTB Everett Realty, LLC v. Mass. Gaming Comm’n, No. SJC-13196 (May 23, 2022), the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court revived a property owner’s Penn Central takings claim, reversing the trial court grant of summary judgment to the Commission.

This one deals with the intricacies of gambling law and the process necessary to approve the operation of a casino — subjects that we can’t claim to fully understand — so bear with us if there are any inaccuracies.

FBT purchased vacant land which was contaminated and required extensive cleanup. It looked into a variety of possible uses, including a storage facility or big box retain. But two years later, Massachusetts legalized casino gambling and created the Commission. Its duties include issuing gambling licenses.

A branch of the Wynn casino operation wanted the property. It entered into an option agreement with FBT under which it would buy the land if Wynn…

Continue Reading Mass SJC Revives Penn Central Takings Claim Because Casino Comm’n Might Have Altered The Deal